1992
Paul Kamerer Hartville - HS / 1939
Dr. Charles Roger Smith, Jr. - Hartville HS / 1936

1993
Mr. Alton Knowles - Hartville HS / 1924
Mrs. Helen Knowles - Hartville HS / 1926
Marion Werstler - Hartville HS / 1914

1994
Dr. Rolan J. Bingham - Hartville HS / 1957
Connie Watson - Hartville HS / 1956

1995
Ralph M. Besse - Hartville HS / 1922
Dr. Andrew W. Cordier - Hartville HS / 1918

1996
Geraldine R. Myers - Hartville HS / 1942
James A. Stoll - Lake HS / 1958

1997
E. Lang D’Atri - Hartville HS / 1956
Dr. Marie A. Keener - Hartville HS / 1923

1998
No inductees

1999
Reverend Paul E. Fryberger - Hartville HS / 1924
Dr. Von Hardesty - Uniontown HS / 1956

2000
John C. Birk - Uniontown HS / 1951
Delbert Glenn Smith - Uniontown HS / 1939
Dr. Richard E. Werstler - Hartville HS / 1945

2001
Howard Miller, Sr. - Hartville HS

2002
P. Roger Clay - Hartville HS / 1957
Bruce Heisler - Uniontown HS / 1950
Walter Raymond Limbach - Hartville HS / 1949

2003
Dale W. Knowles - Hartville HS / 1931
Lt. Col. Kathryn Frances Nance - Lake HS / 1969
 
2004
Earl Loutzenheiser - Uniontown HS / 1936
Joan Olszeski - Lake HS / 1977
Dr. Tracy Schwab - Lake HS / 1985
 
2005
Debra E. Lautzenhiser Heidrich - Lake HS
William H. Pressler
Alfred H. Tessmer
 
2006
Charles Snyder - Lake HS / 1985
Dr. Robert Wilson Jones - Uniontown HS / 1949
 
2007
Albert J. Brumbaugh - Hartville HS / 1924

2008
Zellers Family - Lake HS / 1923
 
2009
Mr. Lewis Gureri - Lake HS / 1966
 
2010
Mr. Brian Miner - Lake HS / 1991